Wednesday, June 29, 2011

Does This Belong in a Scientific Journal?


The other day I was browsing through recently published papers in PLoS Biology and came across this one.
Field D, Amaral-Zettler L, Cochrane G, Cole JR, Dawyndt P, et al. 2011 The Genomic Standards Consortium. PLoS Biol 9(6): e1001088. doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.1001088.

Abstract

A vast and rich body of information has grown up as a result of the world's enthusiasm for 'omics technologies. Finding ways to describe and make available this information that maximise its usefulness has become a major effort across the 'omics world. At the heart of this effort is the Genomic Standards Consortium (GSC), an open-membership organization that drives community-based standardization activities, Here we provide a short history of the GSC, provide an overview of its range of current activities, and make a call for the scientific community to join forces to improve the quality and quantity of contextual information about our public collections of genomes, metagenomes, and marker gene sequences.
I'm interested in this sort of thing since back in the olden days (1993) I spent a bit of time at GenBank exploring annotation issues with a view to correcting the growing number of errors that were being propagated in online databases.

It's an insoluble problem and I doubt very much that a new organization is going to help.

But that's not what I want to talk about. Near the end of the article in PLoS Biology you find this paragraph.
The Internet has resulted in a Cambrian explosion of productivity and data sharing through the adoption of a huge stack of agreed-upon protocols (standards) that allow many devices and programs to communicate to the transformative benefit of the everyday user [26]. Enabling access to user-generated content is key to harnessing the resources of a distributed community: Flickr has over 5 billion photographs uploaded, and Wikipedia has over 3.5 million English articles as of this writing. Standards for organizing sequence data will be similarly needed as sequencing instruments themselves, especially as these instruments are more and more commoditized and owned by individuals rather than institutions.
I'm sad to find this sort of content-free language creeping into scientific journals. We've been spared up to now but it looks like the 23 scientists listed as authors feel comfortable with this new style of writing.


Losing Charlemagne

Back in October 2009 I published my genealogical connection to Emperor Charlemagne [My Family and Other Emperors]. It is wrong. I relied too much on the information found in Ancestry.com and much of that information is unreliable.

In my case the connection was through Ruhamah Hill (b ~1708) who married John Belden (1728 - ). They were British citizens who lived in Norwalk, Fairfield Country, Connecticut (a colony of Great Britain). The parents of Ruhamah Hill are often listed as William Hill and Abigail Barlow of Greenfield Connecticut but there's no evidence to support this connection. On the other hand, historical records say that Ruhamah Hill is the daughter of Captain John Hill (1669 - 1768?) of Westerley, Rhode Island and this seems much more reasonable since Captain John Hill married Ruhamah Wyer (1670 - ).

There goes my connection to Charlemagne and all of the other notables on the list.

Not to worry. The probability is high that I am a descendant of Charlemagne just like most others with any European blood [Are You a Descendant of Charlemagne?]. There are two other connections in my genealogy. I'm working on conformation.

Ms Sandwalk doesn't seem to have any ancestors that connect to European royalty but she is related to a number of very interesting people. Unfortunately, she's too embarrassed to let me mention them in public.


Monday, June 27, 2011

For Your Amusement


vjtorley (Vincent Joseph Torley) has posted on Uncommon Descent. The title of his posting is Someone’s wrong. Who is it?. The issues is whether the similarities of mammalian embryos is PREDICTED by modern evolutionary theory. PZ Myers says "no" and Ken Miller probably agrees. They are both correct.

Do those similarities provide support for common descent even though they may not have been predicted by evolutionary theory? Yes, they do, in the same sense that common pseudogenes support evolution even though pseudogenes are not a necessary part of modern evolutionary theory.

So here's the question ... who is wrong about this issue?
  1. PZ Myers
  2. Ken Miller
  3. Vincent Joseph Torley



Friday, June 24, 2011

New York Legalizes Same-Sex Marriage


Same-sex marriage is legal in ten countries (Argentina, Belgium, Canada, Iceland, the Netherlands, Norway, Portugal, South Africa, Spain and Sweden). In Canada it has been legal for gays and lesbians to marry since July 20, 2005.

In the United States same-sex is legal in Connecticut, Iowa, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, Vermont, and the District of Columbia). A few hours ago it became legal in New York. I wonder if this will cause other states to make same-sex marriage legal?

The map shows where gays and lesbians have the same rights as other citizens and where those rights are restricted. I think it reflects a deep cultural divide in America and I wonder where this is going to end up? Is it possible that some of the red colored states will eventually change their minds on this issue?

[Image Credit: modified from Wikipedia]

Thursday, June 23, 2011

The Religious Left in Canada


The New Democratic Party's "Faith and Social Justice Commission" has produced a video to prove that you can be religious and socialist.

My position is that religion should be kept out of politics. There should not be a "Faith and Social Justice Commission" sanctioned by the NDP. (Is there also an "Unfaith and Social Justice Commission" for all those atheists who believe in social justice?)

I have no problem with individuals adhering to one religion or another but keep it personal. There's no need to band together in order to influence policy within the government or even within a party. Frankly I don't care why you support socialist progressive policies as long as you do. Don't try and make it look like religion is what motivates you to favor the left because that just makes you look as silly as the right-wing fundamentalists who use religion to defend their position.



[Hat Tip: Canadian Atheist]

For Your Amusement


Bill Dembski has just posted an article titled Who Will Be Michele Bachmann’s Science Advisers?.

This is deeply ironic on many levels. Why would Bachmann need people to advise her about science? So far she's gotten along just fine without knowing a thing about science. A real science adviser would just confuse her.

I wonder if Dembski has anyone in mind? He surely can't be thinking of himself or any of his closest IDiot friends because, as we all know, there are Nobel Laureates who would be far better qualified.



Pretty Money


Canada is about to release a new set of polymer banknotes. Watch the video to see all the security features and the cool windows in the notes. (BTW, is there any country other than the United States that has monocolor money? Is there a reason why the USA makes every denomination of bill the same color?)



What's on these banknotes? The $100 bill depicts Sir Robert L. Borden, Prime Minister of Canada from 1911 to 1920. Here's the description of the other images fron The Bank of Canada.
# Theme: Medical Innovation

Canadians have long been at the frontiers of medical research and as a result have helped to save millions of lives worldwide. Notable Canadian contributions include pioneering the use of insulin to treat diabetes, DNA and genetic research, the invention of the pacemaker, and the first hospital-to-hospital robot-assisted surgery.

Researcher at a microscope

The image of a researcher using a microscope depicts Canada’s long-standing commitment to medical research.

DNA strand


Deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) is the genetic blueprint of life. Canadian researchers have been at the forefront of mapping our human genetic makeup in this field of medical science.

ECG

This electrocardiogram provides a visual cue to Canada’s contributions to heart health, including the invention of the pacemaker by John Hopps in 1950.

Insulin

The discovery of insulin to treat diabetes was made by Canadian researchers Frederick Banting and Charles Best in 1921.
It's nice that Canada is celebrating science.




The $50 dollar bill has a picture of William Lyon Mackenzie King who was Prime Minister from 1921–30 and from 1935–48. The other side has ...
# Theme: CCGS Amundsen, Research Icebreaker

The vastness and splendour of Canada’s northern frontier have helped to shape our cultural identity. The icebreaker plays an important role in the North, keeping Canada’s historic passages open, undertaking marine search and rescue, supporting isolated communities, and participating in international environmental research. The CCGS Amundsen helps Canada—the nation with the world’s longest stretch of Arctic coastline—to remain at the leading edge of Arctic research, providing the world’s oceanographers, geologists and ecologists with unparalleled access to the North.

CCGS Amundsen, Research Icebreaker


The Canadian Coast Guard Ship Amundsen became a research icebreaker in 2003. It is jointly operated by ArcticNet and the Canadian Coast Guard.

“Arctic” in Inuktitut

This syllabic text is taken from Inuktitut, a language of Canada’s Inuit population. It stands for “Arctic.”

Map of Canada’s northern regions

The map on the back of this note shows Canada’s northern regions in their entirety, including Inuit regions of the Arctic. This image was provided by Natural Resources Canada.
More mention of research and another language. The $50 dollar bill has words from three languages (French, English, and Inuktitut. (I think there's only two languages on American bills. )





Tuesday, June 21, 2011

The Summer Solstice and Science Literacy


From time to time my colleagues and I discuss the basic requirements of science literacy. We envisage a group of intelligent people at a party discussing various topics. Let's restrict our discussion to Western European culture.

Everyone agrees that they should be familiar with the basic outlines of history (e.g. who did Paul Revere warn in 1775?) and politics (what's the difference between socialism and capitalism?). Everyone agrees that you would look like an idiot if you didn't know who Will Shakespeare was and what Hamlet said. Everyone agrees that you can't call yourself an intellectual if you don't know the difference between French Impressionists and Michelangelo. You're expected to know something about Socrates and Aristotle. You're expected to know at least a few foreign words and knowledge of a foreign language is almost a requirement.

You should know something about food even if it's only the difference between couche couche and curry. Any "intellectual" should be able to discourse for five minutes on a favorite wine. You get the picture—there are some things that you just have to know if you claim to be literate.

What about science? Are there any things in science that you just have to know if you want to be taken seriously as an informed literate person?

No, there aren't. We've all experienced the situation I describe where a group of non-scientists at a party or bar are showing off their knowledge. Knowledge of science and math is not a requirement. In fact, you get points if you brag about always being too stupid to understand mathematics and dropping it as soon as you could in high school, especially if you're a woman.

Are there scientific facts and concepts that you really should be expected to know if you claim to be literate? Yes there are, and it's up to us to make sure they are widely publicized.

Today's your chance to publicize one of those facts. The summer solstice happens two hours from now no matter where you are on the planet. Ask your non-science friends to explain the summer solstice (Northern Hemisphere). It's one of those simple science things that everyone should know about. Not being able to explain it is like not knowing that Libya is in Africa, Napoleon lost the battle of Waterloo, Charles Dickens wrote Oliver Twist, and Frank Lloyd Wright was an architect.

Can you explain the solstice? If so, you are on the way to scientific literacy. What are some other must-know scientific facts and concepts? Evolution is one. If you don't understand the basic concepts of evolution then you can't clam to be scientifically literate. My point is that I'd like to live in a world where you can't claim to be literate, period, if you aren't scientifically literate.


[Image credit: Wikipedia]

Monday, June 20, 2011

Texas Prayed and God Answered


Back in April, Governor Rick Perry of Texas proclaimed a weekend of prayer (Friday, April 22, 2011, to Sunday, April 24, 2011). Texans were supposed to pray for God to relieve the terrible dought [Pray for Texas].

Bill Maher reminded me that it's been several months since Texans prayed so it's time to analyze the results.

On the site US Drought Monitor there are maps of the USA showing region of drought. The top map below shows the regions with severe drought (dark brown) for April 26, 2011, right after all the praying. The second map (below) shows regions of drought on June 14, 2011.

It looks like God hates Texas and/or Rick Perry. I'm told that Governor Perry is thinking of running for President of the United States. Is this a good idea?





Friday, June 17, 2011

Claremount Coptic Encyclopedia

From the homepage of Claremont Coptic Encyclopedia  homepage:
An invaluable reference tool for Coptic Studies is The Coptic Encyclopedia (Aziz S. Atiya, ed. NY: Macmillan, 1991). This monumental work, with approximately 2800 entries written by 215 scholars, covers treasures of Coptic language and literature; Copto-Arabic literature; Coptic art, architecture, archaeology, history, music, liturgy, theology, spirituality, monasticism; and biblical, apocryphal, social, and legal texts. The encyclopedia was the fruit of years of effort on the part of its Editor-in-Chief, Aziz S. Atiya (1898-1988, Distinguished Professor of History at the University of Utah), and its Principal Investigator, Lola Atiya (1917-2002, Doctor of Humane Letters). Donations by the Coptic communities in the Diaspora, a matching grant from the National Endowment for the Humanities from 1979 to 1990, along with numerous other sources, made the project possible.
In 2009 the Claremont Graduate University (CGU) School of Religion acquired the right to develop an updated and continuously expanding and evolving web-based version of The Coptic Encyclopedia. Since then, the Claremont Coptic Encyclopedia (CCE) has been gradually posting the articles of the 1991 Coptic Encyclopedia and will be continuously adding updates and new topics from the growing body of scholarship in Coptic studies at worldwide institutions. Again, the participation of the Coptic community in envisioning and funding this project was instrumental in the project coming to fruition. The partnership of CGU and the Coptic community is one of the missions of the Council for Coptic Studies at the CGU School of Religion. Please visit the Council’s website at http://www.cgu.edu/pages/5446.asp.

Thanks to Chuck Jones

Creationist Logic

Help me out, dear readers. I can't for the life of me figure out the logic behind the latest posting at Uncommon Descent: If you make a prediction and it doesn’t happen ….

I'm serious. Although I often make fun of the IDiots, I usually try hard to understand the points they are trying to make so I can expose them as nonsensical. But this one has me completely stumped. On the surface the author seems to be saying that "Darwinism" made a prediction "based on core principles" that wasn't fulfilled. This is bad for "Darwinism."

What is that prediction?

The author ("News") starts with a quotation from The Myth of Junk DNA.
In 2010, University of California Distinguished Professor of Ecology & Evolutionary Biology John C. Avise published a book titled Inside the Human Genome: A Case for Non-Intelligent Design, in which he wrote that "noncoding repetitive sequences–'junk DNA'–comprise the vast bulk (at least 50%, and probably much more) of the human genome." Avise argued that pseudogenes, in particular, are evidence against intelligent design. For example, "pseudogenes hardly seem like genomic features that would be designed by a wise engineer. Most of them lie scattered along the chromosomes like useless molecular cadavers." To be sure, "several instances are known or suspected in which a pseudogene formerly assumed to be genomic ‘ junk’ was later deemed to have a functional role in cells. But such cases are almost certainly exceptions rather than the rule. And in any event, such examples hardly provide solid evidence for intelligent design; instead, they seem to point toward the kind of idiosyncratic tinkering for which nonsentient evolutionary processes are notorious."

Jonathan Wells, The Myth of Junk DNA (Seattle: Discovery Institute Press, 2011), pp. 26-27
This is a pretty accurate representation of what John Avise actually says except that it juxtaposes two separate facts. It's true that repetitive DNA sequences—mostly defective transposons—make up about half our genome. Then there's pseudogenes. They are found in the other half and they make up about 1% of the human genome.

Avise, and many others, point out that the presence of pseudogenes is inconsistent with good design and therefore poses a problem for Intelligent Design Creationism.1 I note that the IDiots have consistently refused to address this problem. Instead, they try and convince their followers that pseudogenes don't exist.

Here's what Avise says in his book Inside the Human Genome: A Case for Non-intelligent design (p. 115). You can see that Wells accurately represented the actual argument that he (Avise) was making.
At face value, pseudogenes hardly seem like genomic features that would be designed by a wise engineer. Most of them lie scattered among the chromosome like useless molecular cadavers. This sentiment does not preclude the possibility that an occasional pseudogene is resuscitated such that it contributes positively to cellular operations, several instances are known or suspected in which a pseudogene formerly assumed to be genomic "junk" was later deemed to have a functional role in cells. But such cases are almost certainly exceptions and not the rule. And in any event, such examples hardly provide solid evidence for intelligent design; instead, they seem to point toward the kind of idiosyncratic genetic tinkering for which nonsentient evolutionary evolutionary processes are notorious.
It's important to make sure you understand the argument that Avise and others are making. When looking at the big picture the presence of thousands of pseudogenes in the human genome is a challenge for those who argue for Intelligent Design Creationism. The fact that a handful of these regions were misidentified as pseudgenes and now turn out to have a function cannot be taken as evidence that all of the 20,000 known pseudogenes have a function.

So, how does Wells deal with this challenge to his belief? On the next page of his book (p. 27) he says ...
But Is It True?

The arguments by Dawkins, Miller, Shermer, Collins, Kitcher, Coyne and Avise rest on the premise that most non-coding DNA is junk, wihout any significnat biological function. Yet a virtual flood of recent evidence shows that they are mistaken. Much of the DNA they claim to be "junk" actually performs important functions in living cells.

The following chapters cite hundreds of scientific articles (many of them freely accessible on the Internet) that testify to those functions—and those articles are only a small sample of a large and growing body of literature on the subject. This does not mean that the authors of those articles are critics of evolution or supporters of intelligent design. Indeed, most of them interpret the evidence within an evolutionary framework. But many of them explicitly point out that the evidence refutes the myth of junk DNA.
This is a classic "bait-and-switch." The argument from Avise and the others is mostly about the presence of pseudogenes. There is solid evidence that many pseudogenes are completely non-functional. There is evidence that non-functional pseudogenes have been inherited from common ancestors, strongly suggesting that the genes were inactivated in ancient ancestors and passed down to modern species as the evolved.

This argument is NOT about "most noncoding DNA." It's about that 1% of the genome that contains known pseudogenes. Unless that point is addressed directly (it isn't) then Wells is guilty of ignoring one of the main arguments of his critics.

But that's not the point of this posting. I'm concerned about the point that "News" makes in the recent posting on Uncommon Descent. He/she says ...
Darwinism predicts something, based on its core principles, and it doesn’t happen. And there are no consequences? Only on planet Darwin. Where all correct predictions originate in Darwin’s theory and are grandfathered as such by his loyal heirs. All incorrect predictions are “proved” to have originated elsewhere, no matter where they actually originated.
What are these predictions of "Darwinism"? It's surely not pseudogenes since no evolutionary theory that I know of predicted pseudogenes. Bacteria don't have many pseudogenes and that's perfectly consistent with evolutionary theory. Plant genomes have lots of pseudogenes and that's perfectly consistent with evolutionary theory. Yeast has a few pseudogenes but not nearly as many as plants and that's perfectly consistent with modern evolutionary theory.

Is "News" referring to junk DNA in general? That's not a prediction of "Darwinism" or any evolutionary theory that I know of. The fact that bacteria have very little junk DNA has never been taken as a fact that overthrows modern evolutionary theory. I'm unaware of any evolutionary biologist who predicted back in the 1960s that most of the mammalian genome would be junk and that this prediction was a requirement of modern evolutionary theory. The arguments of Avise et al. are not based on the "premise" that most of our genome is junk, they're based on the evidence that pseudogenes exist.

No prediction was made so no prediction has been refuted. The point that "News" is making seems illogical.

Unless I'm missing something obvious.

What about the predictions of the IDiots? Casey Luskin explains it [Intelligent Design and the Death of the "Junk-DNA" Neo-Darwinian Paradigm].
Proponents of intelligent design have long maintained that Neo-Darwinism's widely held assumption that our cells contain much genetic "junk" is both dangerous to the progress of science and wrong. As I explain here, design theorists recognize that "Intelligent agents typically create functional things," and thus Jonathan Wells has suggested, "From an ID perspective, however, it is extremely unlikely that an organism would expend its resources on preserving and transmitting so much ‘junk'." [4] Design theorists have thus been predicting the death of the junk-DNA paradigm for many years: ...
and in Another Intelligent Design Prediction Fulfilled: Function for a Pseudogene ...
Darwinists have long made an argument from ignorance, where our lack of present knowledge of the function for a given biological structure is taken as evidence that there is no function and the structure is merely a vestige of evolutionary history. Darwinists have commonly made this mistake with many types of "junk" DNA, now known to have function. In contrast, intelligent agents design objects for a purpose, and therefore intelligent design predicts that biological structures will have function.2
Here's another prediction, according to Barry Arrington on Uncommon Descent [FAQ4 is Open for Comment].
ID does not make scientifically fruitful predictions.

This claim is simply false. To cite just one example, the non-functionality of “junk DNA” was predicted by Susumu Ohno (1972), Richard Dawkins (1976), Crick and Orgel (1980), Pagel and Johnstone (1992), and Ken Miller (1994), based on evolutionary presuppositions. In contrast, on teleological grounds, Michael Denton (1986, 1998), Michael Behe (1996), John West (1998), William Dembski (1998), Richard Hirsch (2000), and Jonathan Wells (2004) predicted that “junk DNA” would be found to be functional.

The Intelligent Design predictions are being confirmed and the Darwinist predictions are being falsified. For instance, ENCODE’s June 2007 results show substantial functionality across the genome in such “junk DNA” regions, including pseudogenes.

Thus, it is a matter of simple fact that scientists working in the ID paradigm carry out and publish research, and they have made significant and successful ID-based predictions.
It seems like it's the IDiots that have hitched their star to a prediction about junk DNA. If any genome turns out to have a substantial amount of junk DNA then Intelligent Design Creationism is refuted. As it turns out, many genomes do have a lot of junk DNA in spite of what Jonathan Wells would have you believe. Thus, Intelligent Design Creationism is no longer a credible scientific hypothesis.

But you knew that already, didn't you?


1. Most scientists actually argue a more specific point; namely, that the conservation of specific pseudogenes in different species is an especially serious problem for Intelligent Design Creationists.

2. It's interesting that Casey Luskin seems to know something about the motivations of the intelligent designer because when scientists point out that the genome doesn't look like it was designed this is not taken as an argument against the IDiot position. Instead it's taken as illegitimate science as pointed out by Wells in his book (p. 103), "Do arguments based on speculations about a creator or designer have a legitimate place in science? Not according to Canadian biologist Steven Scadding, who once wrote that although he accepted evolutionary theory, he objected to defending it on the grounds that a creator would or would not do certain things. 'Whatever the validity of this theological claim,' Scadding concluded, 'it certainly cannot be defended as a scientific statement, and thus should be given no place is a scientific discussion of evolution."

M. Albarrán Martínez, Prosopographia asceticarum aegyptiarum

Prosopographia asceticarum aegyptiarum


Aut.: María Jesús Albarrán Martínez


Corpus prosopográfico recopilado a través de fuentes literarias, papirológicas y epigráficas, que recoge los datos biográficos de las ascetas egipcias atestiguadas durante el periodo cronológico de la Antigüedad Tardía (siglos IV- VIII d.C.), ordenados de acuerdo con una tipología claramente establecida. Este estudio, cuyo cuerpo fundamental lo constituye una nómina femenina ascética, está precedido por una introducción en la que se explica en qué consiste el volumen, la metodología de recopilación de los datos onomásticos, ros estudios anteriores sobre esta cuestión y las fuentes utilizadas. Cierra el volumen un índice de fuentes citadas que mejorará notablemente su consulta.


Colección DVCTVS,1
Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas
Madrid, 2010
Dpto. de Publicaciones del CSIC
Ficheros asociados:
albarran-1.pdf (book cover only)

Thursday, June 16, 2011

Junk Poll Results


Here are the results of the most recent poll on junk DNA. Below it is the result from several years ago. I realize that the questions are different but the shift toward favoring junk DNA is still a surprise. I'd like to think it's because more and more Sandwalk readers are becoming aware of the science behind junk DNA but it could be just that more "junkers" are reading my blog.

Is there anyone out there who changed their minds over the past few years? Is The Myth of Junk DNA going to convert everyone to rejecting junk DNA? I'll have to do another poll in six months to see if the Intelligent Design Creationists are having an impact.






Zoë and Window Shopping


Don't you just hate it when bloggers post cute pictures of their children, grandchildren, cats, or molluscs?

Tough. Here's my granddaughter, Zoë, window shopping in Barcelona (Spain) a few weeks ago. The window looked so inviting she decided to check out the shop.

She's only 16 months old and already enjoys shopping!

(Zoë took her parents to Barcelona to meet up with Ms. Sandwalk and our nephew for a week of zoo's, Cava, and Gaudí. You can read all about it on leslie jane moran.)




Omnisaurus Games


My number one son1, Gordon Moran, is a texture artist working for a video game company in Vancouver. He has hooked up with his programmer friend Kevin Forbes to found Omnisaurus Games. They are working on an iPhone/iPad game and the unique thing about this is that you can follow their progress on their blog. Did you ever wonder what goes into to making a fabulous app?

Omnisaurus Games is an independent game developer currently developing games for the iPhone, iPad, and iPod Touch. Founded May 2011 in Vancouver, Canada by Kevin Forbes and Gordon Moran, we stress open game development, meaning we share every aspect of our development cycle with you the players. Follow our game development journey through our blog, twitter, facebook, or rss feed. Watch our game grow from the conceptual phase, all the way through the entire development cycle. We regularly post our work in progress builds so that you can test them out online and most importantly give us your feedback and great ideas. After all, we’re making these games for you, so shouldn’t you have a say in how they’re made? Most importantly, keep in touch. We’d love to hear anything you have to say about our games, any games, or life in general. We’ll try really hard to implement the best and most popular ideas into our games and reward the most helpful suggestions and ideas with free copies of our game when it launches. We look forward to hearing from you!


1. Note for the irony deficient - whenever someone says this it usually means they only have one son/daughter. Note that I did not say "number one child" 'cause that would have gotten me in trouble.

A Visit from Rick


It was late in the day when I heard a knock on my office door. I opened it to discover a strange man I hadn't seen in many years he introduced me to his wife and son. Rick Nicholson is a former graduate student in my lab. He got his Ph.D. 25 years ago ("The HSP70 Multi-Gene Family in Saccharomyces cerevisiae.") Rick was the first person to clone and sequence the yeast BiP gene.

Rick went from Toronto to Strasbourg (France) to work in Pierre Chambon's lab and from there he went to Australia. He is currently Professor at the Hunter Medical Research Institute in Newcastle, NSW where he works on peptide hormones expressed during pregnancy in humans.

I've reached the age where it's a real thrill to remember the "olden days" and how much better they were than today. Over dinner, Rick and I agreed that graduate students and young professors were much better 25 years ago than they are today.1

We tried to remember everyone who was in the the lab during the early 1980's. Fortunately there was a list in Rick's thesis (undergraduates. graduate students, post-docs): Sean Blaine, Kim Bird, Eric Degan, Monica Fuchs, David Lowe, Marc Perry, Andrea Townsend, Sharon Shtang, Scott Young and Kee Wan. I know where most of them are but I haven't seen some of them for decades. That's sad.

Rick and his family are on their way to Strasbourg to celebrate Pierre Chambon's 80th birthday. When I reach 80 I'll have to throw a big party so I can invite all my former colleagues and students.


1. I recently had dinner with my former Ph.D. supervisor and we reached the same conclusion only it was for 40 years ago. Isn't that strange?

Wednesday, June 15, 2011

J.M. Modrzejewski, Droit et justice dans le monde grec (J.Urbanik ed.)

Droit et justice dans le monde grec et hellénistique
by Joseph Mélèze Modrzejewski, edited by Jakub Urbanik
xxii-565 pp., 3 col pls. (Journal of Juristic Papyrology 2011)
ISBN-13: 978-83-918250-9-9
ISBN-10: 83-918250-9-4


Table of Contents:
Préface (par Eva Cantarella) – Avant-propos


I. Sources du Droit
1. La loi dans l'antiquité
2. Droit ptolémaïque
3. Prostagmata et diagrammata
4. L'ordonnance sur les cultures


II. La justice à l’œuvre
5. Adikia
6. La justice des Lagides
7. Continuités égyptiennes
8. Un partage de compétences
9. Une préhistoire des droits de l’homme


III. Délits et sanctions
10. L'homicide
11. Le prix du sang
12. La délation
13. Le délit religieux
14. L'injure verbale
15. L'apostasie
16. L'apotympanismos


IV. Actes privés
17. Le document privée: essai d’une taxonomie
18. La famille en droit hellénistique
19. La famille: le témoignage des lettres privées
20. La famille: pères et fils


V. Continuités grecques dans le monde romain
21. Comment être Grec en Égypte sous l’empire?
22. La décade contre l’hebdomade
23. Les titulatures impériales
24. Un empire universel

Monday, June 13, 2011

I PAPIRI LETTERARI CRISTIANI (Gedankschrift Mario Naldini)

I PAPIRI LETTERARI CRISTIANI
Atti del convegno internazionale di studi in memoria di Mario Naldini. Firenze, 10-11 giugno 2010,
a cura di Guido Bastianini e Angelo Casanova,


Firenze, Istituto Papirologico "G. Vitelli" 2011,
pp. VI, 210 + XXVII tavv., euro 50
ISBN 978 88 87829 45 7


Premessa (G. Bastianini - A. Casanova), 
    pp. V-VI
Lectori salutem (C. Austin), 
    p. 1
C. NARDI, Mario Naldini e la papirologia,
     pp. 3-21
R. S. BAGNALL, The Readers of Christian Books: Further Speculations, 
    pp. 23-30
G. BASTIANINI - G. CAVALLO, Un nuovo frammento di lettera festale (PSI inv. 3779), 
    pp. 3-45
P. PARSONS, A People of the Book?, 
    pp. 47-57
J. CHAPA, Su demoni e angeli. Il Salmo 90 nel suo contesto, 
    pp. 59-90
A. CARLINI - M. BANDINI, Il Pastore di Erma: nuove testimonianze e vecchi problemi, 
    pp. 91-105
E. GIANNARELLI, Papiri, letteratura cristiana antica e apocrifi del Nuovo Testamento:
    apporti e problemi vecchi e nuovi, 
    pp. 107-122
O. ZWIERLEIN, Griechische Papyri in der Überlieferung der Acta Apostolorum Apocrypha,
     pp. 123- 145
P. MARRASSINI, Scoperta e riscoperta dell'Apocalisse di Pietro fra greco, arabo ed etiopico,
      pp. 147-160
J. GASCOU, La montagne d'Antinoopolis, hagiographie et papyrus, 
    pp. 161-171
M. STROPPA, Un papiro inedito del Fisiologo (PSI inv. 295), 
    pp. 173-192
D. MINUTOLI - R. PINTAUDI, Un codice biblico su papiro della collezione Schoyen MS 187 (Esodo IV 16- VII 21), 
     pp. 193-205

Thursday, June 9, 2011

DEMOTIC CONGRESS: TITLES AND ABSTRACTS OF PAPERS (so far)

DEMOTIC CONGRESS: TITLES AND ABSTRACTS OF PAPERS RECEIVED AS OF 8 JUNE 2011

Priestly Allowances in the Temple of Jeme
Maha AKEEL (Helwan)
A demotic ostracon in the collection of the Ashmolean Museum dates to the early Roman Period. It includes a list of amounts of wheat representing the allowances distributed to the priests in the temple of Jeme. The points of interest in this list are: (a) the appearance of women (priestesses) as recipients of wheat allowances, giving another dimension to the role played by Egyptian priestesses; (b) olyra (emmer wheat) is the usual crop used for priestly stipends not wheat as mentioned in this list; and (c) one of the allowances was received by an agent in the name of a priest.

The Griffith Papyri in Oxford
Carolin ARLT (Würzburg)
The Ashmolean Museum houses the collection of the Griffith papyri, which were found in Soknopaiou Nesos and date to the Ptolemaic Period. 75 documentary texts were published by Edda Bresciani in 1975. The announced publication of the remainder of the papyri was never realized. Part of the project ‘Dime im Fayum – ein Tempel im Spannungsfeld von Tradition und Multikulturalität im hellenistisch-römischen Ägypten’, which is based at Würzburg University, is the publication and analysis of this ‘new’ material as well as a re-edition of the papyri already published by Bresciani. This paper will give an overview of the unpublished documentary material.

Demotic Texts from the Embalmer’s Cache of Menekhibnekau
Ladislav BAREŠ, Jiří JANÁK and Renata LANDGRÁFOVÁ (Prague)
The burial complex of Menekhibnekau belongs to a group of large Late Period shaft tombs that were built in the south-western part of the Abusir necropolis between approximately 530 and 525 B.C.E. While the superstructure of the tomb was almost completely destroyed by later stone quarrying, its underground parts were much better preserved, including the burial chamber of this dignitary who held more than twenty titles, including those of the highest rank. Inside the area of his tomb (but separated from its underground parts), a large embalmers’ cache was found, consisting of a shaft and an underground corridor with three large niches.
Within the embalmers’ cache, over 300 large amphorae were discovered. About a tenth of these bore hieratic and demotic texts, and within some of the amphorae, smaller vessels were found, again often inscribed with hieratic and demotic texts.
The hieratic texts identify materials used for mummification and days of the mummification process on which they were to be used. The demotic inscriptions are more varied, even though they are less numerous. They identify materials used for mummification – sometimes even exactly the same materials as the hieratic texts, but also record data completely unrelated to the process of mummification, such as the date of import of wine on an amphora originally from Samos.
Our paper offers an analysis and evaluation of these demotic inscriptions and addresses the issue of why the embalmers’ workshop would contain vessels inscribed in two scripts (as well as, in part, a mixture of these two scripts).

The Ancient Near Eastern Background of Demotic Legal Terminology
Alejandro F. BOTTA (Boston)
Building upon the previous research of Muffs (1969); Porten (1968, 1992); Ritner (2002), and others, and my own ongoing research project, “A Dictionary of Ancient Near Eastern Legal Terms and Formulae”, this paper surveys Demotic legal terms and formulae placing them in their wider ancient Near Eastern context. The resulting data provide clearer and quantifiable evidence of both continuity and innovation within the Demotic-Egyptian and other ancient Near Eastern legal traditions. At the same time, they offer the necessary material for the comparative study of ancient Near Eastern formulae, and for the investigation of interaction and influence of legal traditions within the ancient Near East.

Deux papyrus inédits de Dime conservés à la Sorbonne
Marie-Pierre CHAUFRAY (Paris)
En 2008, deux rouleaux de papyrus ont été déroulés à l’Institut de Papyrologie de la Sorbonne. L’un d’entre eux (P. Sorb. Inv. 1447) est un contrat de mariage démotique avec une souscription grecque, provenant de Dime et datant de la fin de l’époque ptolémaïque. Le second papyrus (P. Sorb. Inv. 1148) est un extrait de la comptabilité du temple de Soknopaios contenant deux reçus de l’époque romaine, dont l’un est un versement de la part d’un collège de lésônis d’Isis. Ces documents inédits viennent compléter le corpus récemment publié par S. Lippert et M. Schentuleit dans les Demotische Dokumente aus Dime (Volume II: Quittungen, Wiesbaden, 2006 ; Volume III: Urkunden, Wiesbaden, 2010).

The Horhotep Letters from North Saqqara
Sue DAVIES (London) and H.S. SMITH (Huntingdon)
In this paper we will present four damaged demotic letters on papyrus mentioning a man named Horhotep found at the Sacred Animal Necropolis site in 1971/2.

Trismegistos People: A New Prosopographic and Onomastic Tool
Mark DEPAUW (Leuven)
The project Creating Identities in Graeco-Roman Egypt (K.U.Leuven, 2008-2012) studies the way people constructed identities through personal names in Egypt, 800 BC – AD 800. This paper introduces the various related databases which were developed for this purpose and which will be made available online in the summer of 2011. Currently some 60,000 Demotic references to people are included (some 15% of the total), as well as some 8,000 names which are attested in Egyptian. Some preliminary results of regional variation and chronological evolution of the anthroponyms will be presented.

Demotic Grammar in the Twenty-first Century: Propensities, Problems, Prospects
Leo DEPUYDT (Providence)
At the Seventh International Conference (1999) and in the contribution to its acts, I listed 19 studies on Demotic grammar published in the decade before, trying to show how the grammar of Demotic is less often studied than that of the other stages of Egyptian. Since then, 24 more studies have come to my attention. This paper aims to, (1) discuss recent trends, (2) address obstinate problems, and (3) discern topics in need of investigation. Special attention will be paid to sentence patterns as a critical principle of organization for the grammar of all stages of Egyptian.
The study of Demotic grammar benefits not only Demotists. Demotic is a stage of Egyptian, whose history is the longest attested of any language, making it an extraordinary laboratory for the study of language evolution. Middle Egyptian receives disproportionate attention because of its status as classical idiom imitated down to the end of Egyptian history. But the second half of the history of Egyptian, encompassing Late Egyptian, Demotic, and Coptic, is much more transparently and amply documented than the first, Old and Middle Egyptian, hence offering superior conditions for studying language evolution.
Inevitably, the road from Late Egyptian to Coptic passes through Demotic.

De l’emploi du démotique sur les stèles du Sérapéum de Memphis
Didier DEVAUCHELLE (Lille)
À partir d’un corpus délimité, celui des stèles du Sérapéum de Memphis, peut-on comprendre pourquoi les scribes ont recours à telle ou telle écriture, voire à deux écritures pour une même stèle ? Pour tenter de répondre à cette question, je m’intéresserai à la place occupée par la cursive démotique dans ce corpus et à son emploi en regard des écritures hiéroglyphiques et hiératiques. Je présenterai aussi les différentes formes attestées de cette cursive dans le corpus, ainsi que quelques traits particuliers de langue démotique.

The Demotic Rubrics in the Artemis Liturgical Papyrus
Jacco DIELEMAN (Los Angeles)
The Artemis Liturgical Papyrus (P. Louvre N 3135 + P. Vienna ÄS 3871) is an unpublished Egyptian manuscript preserving a selection of ritual texts used in the cult of Sokar- Osiris. These temple liturgies were adapted for the burial of a private individual named Artemis, daughter of Herais. She likely lived in Thebes around the time Egypt became a Roman province. The liturgies are written in Classical Egyptian in hieratic cursive and, uniquely, alternate with rubrics in Demotic, prescribing when and where the priest and choir recite the incantations. The liturgies are thus combined into a meaningful ritual, progressing from embalming hall to the burial chamber. In this presentation I will discuss the Demotic rubrics and propose identifications of the various stages in the ritual proceedings.

Statistics and the Structure of Demotic
John GEE (Provo)
Large databases such as the Thesaurus Linguae Aegyptiae provide an opportunity to examine and quantifiably describe Demotic in ways that are not possible working through individual texts. Statistical analysis can be either informative or not depending on the type of questions asked. In this paper I will examine how statistical patterns of words can make certain aspects of Demotic more understandable. These aspects include when alphabetic spellings are used, and the advantages and disadvantages of the current textbook of Demotic.

Who Was Who and What He Did in Demotic and Greco-Roman “Historical” Literature.
Roberto B. GOZZOLI (Bangkok)
Historic or pseudo-historic literature includes a miscellany of different texts: the Pe-dubastis cycle, the Demotic Chronicle, the Prophecy of the Lamb, the Oracle of the Potter, Papyrus Vandier, and the Setne II story are some examples. To this group, some texts from the Archive of Hor relative to the political history of Alexandria should be added. As many of them have been previously studied by the present writer, dealing in particular with the reasons why a particular historical character was chosen in the context of when the particular textual version was written, the discussion now will focus on the historicity of events as given in the narrative of some of these texts. The names of the protagonists and their actions therefore will be the subject of such investigation.
The level of historicity for some of them is certainly open to discussion, and the concept of historical flavouring can be more acceptable (Thutmose III in Setne II, Merneptah in the Vandier papyrus). But the analysis of historical accuracy and consciousness in the Demotic Chronicle and the other prophetic literature, as well as the Sesostris image as present in Greek literature (Herodotus and Sesonchis Romance) can be reviewed in the light of the events as actually known from the historical and other contemporary sources.

Le vocabulaire des associations dans les sources grecques et démotiques
Cassandre HARTENSTEIN (Strasbourg)
Dans un article publié peu de temps avant sa mort, Michel Muzynski s’est intéressé aux associations religieuses égyptiennes, et notamment à la terminologie employée pour les nommer dans la documentation papyrologique et épigraphique : swn.t en démotique (la lecture Xny.t n’avait pas encore été adoptée) et ἡ σύνοδος en grec. Si l’on étend cette étude aux textes de l’époque hellénistique, romaine et byzantine, concernant ou mentionnant une association tous types confondus, il apparaît qu’il existe d’autres termes et constructions, dont les attestations évoluent dans le temps.

Numbers and Nouns in Demotic: Recent Work from the Chicago Demotic Dictionary
Brittany HAYDEN and Janet JOHNSON (Chicago)
Numbers tend not to be discussed in much detail in Demotic grammars, beyond the simple observation that numbers usually follow the nouns they are counting. However, recent work at the Chicago Demotic Dictionary Project has shown that there is much greater variation in the ways numbers and nouns interact.
For example, the common understanding that feminine numbers are used to count feminine nouns is made more complicated when feminine units are involved. One such complication is found in Camel Bone Pisa 2, B2/2, where we find bnv.(t) mw 1.t "1 banatos- measure of water." In this case and others like it, the feminine number agrees with the feminine unit as opposed to the masculine noun. Where we have a masculine noun followed by a feminine number, we can therefore understand that a feminine unit must be missing.
This paper will present an overview of the variation we have observed in areas including the gender of numbers, numbers in association with genitival constructions, and word order. We will also demonstrate how this new information can help demotists to fill in lacunae and to better understand texts.

Relative Drogenquantitierungen mit Dnf im Wiener medizinischen Papyrus (P. Wien D 6257)
Friedhelm HOFFMANN (Munich)
Der große Wiener medizinische Papyrus D 6257, dessen Neubearbeitung ich vorbereite, ist das römerzeitliche Manuskript einer umfangreichen Rezeptsammlung. An mehreren Stellen wird in den Angaben, wieviel von einer Droge zu verwenden ist, das Wort Dnf verwendet. Es ist nicht offensichtlich, wie diese Einträge zu verstehen sind. Mein Lösungsansatz ist im Titel meines Vortrags angedeutet – aber das ist erst die halbe Wahrheit.

Light from Obscurity? Fragments of a Setne Story in Copenhagen and Florence
Richard JASNOW (Baltimore)
A few years ago, Kim Ryholt kindly suggested to me that I work on fragments of a Setne tale preserved in both Copenhagen and Florence. Once I had also generously received the permission of Prof. Guido Bastianini, Director of the Instituto Papirologico “G. Vitelli,” to study the pieces in that collection, I began to examine the material. I offer here an interim report on my progress. The chief obstacle to the research is the sad condition of the fragments; few are large enough to yield connected sense. It may, unfortunately, be impossible ever to recover the gist of the narrative. Still, as we Demoticists know, even fragmentary texts can be significant, and fragments must be published if parallels or addi- tional pieces of the papyrus are to be identified. In that spirit I present this material. I have been preparing digital “facsimiles” to expedite study of the fragments, and will use these as the basis for my talk.

Demotisch: Recht und Mathematik
Birgit JORDAN (Munich)
In meiner Dissertation untersuche ich das Demotische als rechtliche und mathematische Fachsprache, primär anhand der Fragmente pCairo JE 89127–30 und JE 89137–43 (sog. legal code of Hermopolis). Dieser ungewöhnliche Textträger lädt aufgrund seiner Länge und dank der identischen Erhaltungschancen seiner beiden Texte zu einem solchen Vergleich ein: vom äußeren Aufbau der Texte auf dem Textträger über die Grammatik bis zur Semantik, die noch einige ungelöste Probleme bietet.
Dabei erweist sich der rechtliche Text als streng logisch aufgebaute Struktur, die wesentliche Forderungen an eine formale Sprache erfüllt, während der mathematische Text mit seinem rezeptartigen Aufbau eher in der wohl vorwiegend didaktischen Tradition älterer Vorbilder verbleibt. Erstaunlich ist, dass der Rechtstext in der neueren Rechtsgeschichte kaum oder nur ziemlich oberflächlich rezipiert wird, obwohl er interessantes Vergleichsmaterial zum römischen Recht bietet, dem zumindest in der kontinentaleuropäischen Tradition noch immer Referenzcharakter zugesprochen wird. Meine Arbeit ist inhaltlich und auch institutionell ägyptologisch (Betreuer: Friedhelm Hoffmann, LMU München) und rechtshistorisch (Rechtsgeschichte, Max Planck-Institut und Goethe- Universität Frankfurt, http://www.jura.uni-frankfurt.de/imprs/kollegiat/jordan.html) verankert, und ich möchte in meinem Vortrag die Chancen und Probleme darstellen, die sich in einem solchen interdisziplinären Projekt zeigen.

ComplexEdition – A Web-Based Workbench for Digital Philology
Clemens LIEDTKE (Stuttgart)
Scientific edition of historic text sources in many cases faces fragmented material, and working with standard office tools has its own challenges if non-western writing systems or complex structures like synoptical text organization are required. Moreover, international cooperation results in groups of editors working at different institutions or places. As a completely web-based software solution currently under development, ComplexEdition’s aim is to combine best practices of philological editing procedures with an easy-to-use software interface, based on well established IT standards in digital philology. In close collaboration with the Myth of the Sun’s Eye Project, the development of ComplexEdition is focused on establishing a complete digital workflow starting from work- group management, placement and reconstruction of fragments and text editing as well as handling of word lists/dictionaries, comments, footnotes and critical apparatus up to preparing high quality editions ready for publication, either in print or online.

The Myth of the Sun’s Eye Project
Sandra L. LIPPERT (Tübingen)
In recent years, several new manuscripts of the text generally known as the ‘Myth of the Sun’s Eye’ have turned up. In 2009, holders of publication rights to these papyri joined in the Myth of the Sun’s Eye Study Group and a first meeting took place in Copenhagen in January 2010. The Myth of the Sun’s Eye Project –at present consisting of Frank Feder, Sandra Lippert, Jürgen Osing, Joachim Quack, Kim Ryholt, Mark Smith, and Ghislaine Widmer – aims at a complete synoptic (re-)edition of all published and unpublished manuscripts including the Greek translation. It is expected that the additional material will more than double the known amount of text; it might even allow us to compile the first complete running text of the Myth. In order to cope with the challenge of jointly editing and publishing ten different manuscripts in various degrees of fragmentary preservation, an online workbench is currently being created that will be applicable to other Egyptological and non-Egyptological edition projects as well.

Early Demotic Documents from Memphis
Cary MARTIN (London)
In 2005 a group of early demotic documents was sold in auction in Paris. The documents belonged to a private collector and had apparently been found near Cairo shortly after the Second World War. There were 14 documents in total and they date to the late Saite or early Persian period. This paper will give a preliminary overview of their contents and highlight some of the interesting information that they contain.

A Palaeography of Demotic Epigraphy / Eine Paläographie der demotischen Epigraphik
Jan MOJE (Berlin)
Palaeographic studies are of major importance in Egyptology, not only for purposes of establishing date and provenance or deciphering words, but also for research on script development, local workshop contexts and socio-cultural embedding of the relevant script(s) in regional society. Palaeographies have been created for hieroglyphs and Hieratic, as well as recently for the Cairo corpus of Demotic papyri. On the other hand, the Demotic epigraphical sources, especially those carved in stone, have generally received less attention from the point of view of palaeography. The study in progress introduced here aims to supply this desideratum. The presentation will give priority to methods, problems and the expected goals of my current project on this topic.

More Papyri from the Archive of Panas son of Espemetis
Brian MUHS (Leiden)
In 1995, P.W. Pestman identified the archive of Panas son of Espemetis, a mortuary priest and moneylender in Thebes in the early Second Century BCE. He attributed to it eight Demotic loan contracts and quitclaims that the British Museum and the British Library purchased from Chauncey Murch in 1901 and 1903 (P. Lond. Gr. III 1200-2 + RecTrav 31, p. 92-98, and P. BM Andrews 5-7, 30-31).
In this paper I will argue that the archive also included two unpublished Demotic accounts in the British Museum (P. BM 10556 and 10557, the former described by Andrews, EVO 17, p. 35). I will also suggest that it may have included a group of mostly unpublished Demotic papyri formerly in the Nathan Elkan Adler collection, unrelated to the archive of Horos son of Nechutes (described by F.Ll. Griffith, The Adler Papyri, p. 65, one published by N.J. Reich, JAOS 56, p. 258-271). I would welcome information about the present location of the latter papyri.

Greek Loanwords in Egypt: the project “Database and Dictionary of Greek Loan-words in Coptic” (DDGLC) and its perspectives for Demotic Studies
Franziska NAETHER (Leipzig)
The “Database and Dictionary of Greek Loanwords in Coptic” project (DDGLC), started in April 2010, is intended to address a major lacuna in Coptic studies by providing a systematic description and analysis of attested loanwords. The phonological, morphological, semantic, and stylistic/ rhetorical aspects of the loanwords in Greek are to be studied, word-class by word-class and for each dialect and sub-dialectal corpus. The intended outcome is an electronic database and a dictionary consisting of entries in alphabetic order. These project results will not only serve the lexicographical needs of Copticists, but will also provide a firm empirical basis upon which to assess questions of grammatical borrowing, on the one hand, and the sociolinguistic context of language contact, on the other. It is intended at a second stage from mid-2012 on to include as well Greek loanwords in older Egyptian languages, namely Demotic and Ptolemaic.
Homepage: www.uni-leipzig.de/~ddglc

Visions of Gods: Some Remarks on pVienna D 6633-6636
Luigi PRADA (Oxford)
pVienna D 6633-6636 are four fragments from a demotic papyrus that probably originates from Soknopaiou Nesos, in the Fayum, and can be dated to the Roman Period, specifically the late second or early third century AD. These fragments belong to a dream interpretation handbook, and constitute a section of it dealing with gods: in each line, one or more deities are named, then a prediction of what will happen in the life of the man who will see them in his dreams follows. The interest of these fragments lies primarily in the divinities that they mention, and in the epithets that these are given.
This paper will offer an overview of the text (including a complete transliteration and translation), analyze the main reading problems, and discuss the religious significance of the gods and goddesses named in it, comparing similar texts (lists and onomastica).

A New Demotic Translation of (Excerpts of) a Chapter of the Book of the Dead
Joachim QUACK (Heidelberg)
This lecture will present a demotic funerary text which contains a translation of excerpts of a chapter of the Book of the Dead. The Middle Egyptian and the Demotic versions will be presented in parallel and questions of the choice of vocabulary and grammatical constructions in the translation will be addressed. The reasons for not translating the full text of the chapter, and the position of this section in the overall structure of the papyrus, will be discussed as well.

Various Renderings of πίναξ in Greek and Demotic in the Medînet Mâdi Ostraca
Micah ROSS (Kyoto) and Dorian Gieseler GREENBAUM (London)
The modalities by which the Greek word πίναξ entered Demotic texts reveal different strategies used by Demotic scribes for adopting loan words. The ostraca of Medînet Mâdi form a linguistically significant corpus. Comprised of both Greek and Demotic texts, these ostraca represent the compositions of a small group of people working in a limited area, within a generation of each other, and capable of communicating with each other. Despite this common ground, the scribes of Medînet Mâdi used different Greek renderings, employed different strategies for adopting the word, transliterated it differently, and possibly used the word in different technical senses.
Whereas Medînet Mâdi represents a socio-linguistically unified adoption of πίναξ, this use can be compared to other uses of πίναξ as a loan-word in Demotic and bilingual texts. Particularly relevant is the London-Leiden Magical Papyrus, which represents a compositional unity. The other texts, including the London-Leiden Magical Papyrus, were subject to different motives and employ different transliterations for πίναξ. However, the astrological context of these passages fits the astrological character of the Medînet Mâdi material.
A linguistic model for the adoption of technical loan-words may be borrowed from other area studies. This model demands modifications and refinements specific to Demotic.

Demotic Parallels for the Hieroglyphic Inscriptions on a Mummy Bed of the Roman Period in Berlin
Mark SMITH (Oxford)
Berlin Äg. Inv. 12442, a coffin in the form of a mummy bed dating to the Roman Period, is decorated with scenes and inscribed with hieroglyphic texts for the afterlife on all four sides. The most recent treatment of its scenes and texts is Dieter Kurth, Materialen zum Totenglauben im römerzeitlichen Ägypten (Hützel, 2010), pp. 138–94. This paper will demonstrate how problematic passages in the hieroglyphic inscriptions on this object can be elucidated with the aid of demotic parallels in an unpublished papyrus in the Bodleian Library, Oxford.

A New Source Concerning the Theology of Sobek in Dime: Papyrus British Library 254 recto
Martin STADLER (Würzburg)
In 1898 the Assistant Keeper of Manuscripts in the British Museum, F.G. Kenyon, mentioned on page XXV of the second volume of his catalogue of the Greek papyri in the British Museum a papyrus with the inventory number CCXIV: ‘List of names, for what purpose is uncertain. Written in fourteen narrow columns, in a very cursive and ill-formed hand of fair size. (...) The writing is on the verso of the papyrus. The recto is occupied by demotic writing, but there are traces of an underlying Greek writing, which has apparently been washed out.’ The papyrus has been transferred to the British Library, and thus, hidden among Greek texts, it may have escaped the notice of demotists. The demotic text is religious in nature and from Dime. Five columns are still preserved, three of them completely. This paper will present a preliminary overview of the text, which deals with Sobek/Sobek lord of Pai, his manifestations and his nature as a cosmic creator. The ancient scribe chose to write the text down using unetymological writings, a practice well-attested among religious compositions from Dime.

Demotic Studies and Enquiry into the Emotions
John TAIT (London)
Written sources in Demotic provide a stimulating if challenging resource for the study of the social and cultural construction of the emotions in Egypt during the period of the script’s currency, the greater part of a millennium. It would not be proper wholly to privi- lege Demotic—or indeed written sources—for this work. Nevertheless, the Demotic material that may be exploited includes a wide range of types, as these are conventionally categorised: documents of many kinds, letters, narratives and wisdom literature, and scientific literature. The present paper takes the converse approach, and sets out some of the rewards for the study of Demotic script and language that emerge from such enquiries into the emotions. The most fruitful areas are naturally in pragmatics, in how aspects of language relate to their context of use, although some issues of lexicography and straightforward grammar arise.

Demotic ‘Cessions’ in the British Museum Collection: A Legal and Historical Analysis
Siân THOMAS (Cambridge)
The British Museum collection includes more than 40 unpublished demotic papyri from the Gebelein area in Upper Egypt (ancient Pathyris and Crocodilopolis). Most are legal and business texts from private archives. They date to between 205 BCE and circa 88 BCE, with a concentration of papyri from the turn of the second to first centuries BCE.
This paper will look at the sX.w n wy (‘documents of being far’, often referred to as ‘cessions’) in the collection. Most Ptolemaic sX.w n wy were drawn up on sales of land and record the seller’s acknowledgement that he has relinquished his claim to the property sold. The British Museum examples are of a different, rarer, type: they confirm the release of rights and obligations created in earlier contracts.
  Like most demotic contracts, these texts provide only limited contextual information. This paper will reconstruct the wider legal transactions that they reflect and explore the use of this document form to record the release of contractual obligations. It will touch on aspects of the practical workings of Egyptian law in the Ptolemaic period, including the interaction of demotic and Greek documents and the use of the arbv (‘trustee, document holder’).

Toponyms in Demotic and Abnormal Hieratic Texts
Herbert VERRETH (Leuven)
For the moment the Trismegistos database (www.trismegistos.org) counts 62 Abnormal Hieratic and 14553 Demotic texts, both documentary and literary. For all these texts we are gathering the references to the toponyms and other 'geographica' they contain. We have already collected 160 Abnormal Hieratic references to 18 different places, and 11469 Demotic references to 998 different toponyms, information which is already available online and will soon be turned into a printed volume. This paper will discuss how we gathered the material, which problems we encountered doing so and which choices we had to make to present the data in a user-friendly way.

Demotic Graffiti in the Valley of the Kings
Steve VINSON (Bloomington)
Every visitor to the royal tombs in the Valley of the Kings has noted that most of the tombs are full of ancient, medieval and modern graffiti. The Greek and (relatively few) Latin graffiti of the tombs was published in the 1920s by Jules Baillet. At the time, Baillet reported that the Demotic graffiti in the Valley of the Kings were to be published by George Bénédite, but no such publication ever appeared, and only a handful of the hundreds of Demotic graffiti from the royal tombs have ever been discussed in print. Beginning in 2005, Steve Vinson, Eugene Cruz-Uribe, and Jacqueline Jay have worked to comprehensively photograph, facsimile and study all of the post-Ramesside, pre-Coptic Egyptian graffiti from the Valley of the Kings, as well as ancient graffiti in the tombs that are neither in Egyptian nor in Greek. We have identified a total of 234 such graffiti, distributed very unequally in the following tombs: KV1 (Ramses VII), KV2 (Ramses IV), KV4 (Ramses XI), KV6 (Ramses IX), KV8 (Merneptah), KV9 (Ramses V/VI), KV11 (Ramses III), KV15 (Sety II). Of these, almost half (107) are in KV2. I will summarize our results so far, and particularly invite suggestions as to problematic graffiti.

Berichtigungsliste and Short Texts
Sven VLEEMING (Trier)
The role the Greek Berichtigungsliste and Sammelbuch play within Greek papyrology is perhaps still little known in demotic studies, so a brief exposé of the intended function of the Demotic Berichtigungsliste and our Short Texts, which are the beginning of an equivalent of the Sammelbuch, may be in order. A sketch of the beginnings of the Greek and demotic research tools in question will provide an opportunity to discuss the workings and the interdependence of the two projects.

Demotic Documentary Texts as Sources for Religious Practices
Alexandra VON LIEVEN (Berlin)
When thinking of textual sources for Ancient Egyptian religion, rituals, myths or hymns to deities come to mind. While these are certainly of great interest, documentary texts are also sometimes very useful, particularly as they do give different sorts of information from the other genres mentioned. While obviously religious texts are often centered on the state religion and its deities, documentary texts are especially valuable as sources for more popular practices.

Looking for Light in the Chamber of Darkness: Recent Work on the Book of Thoth
Karl-Theodor ZAUZICH (Würzburg) and Richard JASNOW (Baltimore)
(NB: This paper will be read by Richard Jasnow)
In this talk Zauzich and I report on recent progress in the study of the Book of Thoth, which was published in 2005. Most significantly perhaps, numerous new fragments have come to light, often brought to our attention by such colleagues as Joachim Quack and Kim Ryholt. Jasnow has also prepared digital handcopies of all the papyri witnesses, and used these as the basis for a greatly enhanced glossary, which will include facsimiles of all words. Several years ago we were able to collate these facsimiles against the originals, thanks to the kindness of those responsible for the individual papyrological collections where they are kept. There have also been extensive published discussions and reviews of the Book of Thoth; these have been naturally most helpful in our own study and restudy of the work. In the near future we hope to offer another volume of the Book of Thoth containing these new fragments, glossaries, and facsimiles of all papyri, as well as addenda on specific points. We are also preparing a “semi-popular” translation which will present a fresh rendering of virtually the entire composition.